Ok let's start with the numbers

completion % 54.3 14th among NFC qbs
yards 2136 11th among NFC
tds 13 T 9th
int 12 T9th
qb rating 71.8 13th

Also let's add in the fact that you can't use the, "oh well at least he's winning a bunch of games" argument. As of right now, the Falcons are the 8th seed in the NFC. He has also come up small when his team most needed him this year.

Here is a list of NFC qb's that should have gotten in over him. In no particular order.

Mark Brunell- Has much better stats than Vick, plus has come up huge in very important games. Amazing comeback in Cowboys1 and total domination in Cowboys2. Those 2 wins have basically put the Skins where they are right now.

Drew Bledsoe- Again much better stats than Vick. I hate the Cowboys, but that won't blind me from realizing that Drew is having a better year than Vick.

Mark Bulger only played in 8 games, but even he is still more deserving than Vick is this year.